Kuhn, Coherentism and Perception
نویسندگان
چکیده
In the latter half of twentieth century, foundationalist approaches to epistemology and philosophy science were widely rejected in favour holist coherentist approaches. Kuhn may be regarded as a contributor this anti-foundationalist tendency. paper, I wish consider extent which Kuhn’s epistemological thinking was nature. This is task that has already begun work Jouni-Matti Kuukkanen. However, go beyond Kuukkanen by raising number questions he does not address. First, present Kuukkanen’s interpretation Kuhn. next section, argue fails show rejects non-doxastic justification coherence relations among beliefs. fourth standard objection coherentism any adequate formulation doctrine must confront, “input objection”. then frame terms model. fifth account able satisfactorily deal with input objection. sixth explore relationship between treatment perception tendency contributed rise coherentism.
منابع مشابه
Coherentism and Belief Fixation
Plantinga argues that cases involving ‘fixed’ beliefs refute the coherentist thesis that a belief’s belonging to a coherent set of beliefs suffices for its having justification (warrant). According to Plantinga, a belief cannot be justified if there is a ‘lack of fit’ between it and its subject’s experiences. I defend coherentism by showing that if Plantinga means to claim that any ‘lack of fit...
متن کاملThree Kinds of Coherentism
This paper aims to show what makes coherentism attractive in comparison to its main competitor, foundationalism. It also aims to show that constraint satisfaction is not the most attractive way to give content to the notion of coherence. In order to achieve these purposes, the paper distinguishes between epistemic, constructive and integrated coherentism. Epistemic coherentism treats coherence ...
متن کاملCoherentism, Reliability and Bayesian Networks
The coherentist theory of justification provides a response to the sceptical challenge: even though the independent processes by which we gather information about the world may be of dubious quality, the internal coherence of the information provides the justification for our empirical beliefs. This central canon of the coherence theory of justification is tested within the framework of Bayesia...
متن کاملKuhn and Scientific Practices
Joseph Rouse Wesleyan University Thomas Kuhn's philosophical work has helped initiate or reinvigorate many of the central themes in the philosophy of science over the past three decades. His claim that appropriate attention to history could decisively transform familiar philosophical of science views was of course prophetic. Kuhn's discussion of meaning change, incommensurability, and the inter...
متن کاملGödel, Kuhn, and Feyerabend
Thomas Kuhn [4] has presented a view of the history of science as a succession of “paradigms” which are not completely comparable with each other. Karl Popper [8] has attacked this view as being relativistic and denying that there is objective scientific truth. Popper seems to be saying that in order for science to be objectively true, every two scientific theories must be completely comparable...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
ژورنال
عنوان ژورنال: The Western Ontario series in philosophy of science
سال: 2023
ISSN: ['2215-1974', '1566-659X']
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-16371-5_1